Friday, December 3, 2010

Jeter's $45MM Seems Fair


Derek Jeter has had a great career, but last year he hit .270 (mediocre)). Nonetheless, he's fielding offers like $45MM for 3 years. Yet, no one seems very angry about exhorbitant pay in athletics, as compared to CEOs. Here's Holman Jenkins over at the WSJ:

Said one fan on a New York paper's website: "As far as the money is concerned, I really don't care what they pay him. It's not my money." If it were catching, this healthy-minded attitude toward the paychecks of our fellow man would make the world a better, happier place.


Jeter clearly has alpha in a narrowly defined sphere that most of us recognize. We can see he is good at what he does--much better than us or anyone we know personally--and thus earns his pay. In contrast, the suspicion is that CEOs are merely involved in a massive crony-capitalism game that discriminates against those who don't have the right family and friends. That strikes many as unfair.

Former Clinton Attorney General Jamie Gorelick made $40MM while running Fannie Mae and the mortgage market into the ground. Rahm Emmanuel made made $16.2 million in his two-and-a-half-years as an investment banker. Bob Rubin pocketed $150MM while working for Citigroup. The list goes on and on (recent OMB director Peter Orzag was just hired as an investment banker by Citibank). These are problematic because we know they are getting paid merely for access--Rubin claims he was totally unaware Citi had $54B in mortgages on their balance sheet, which was probably true--for getting the right person to answer a phone, or bury some exception in the latest 2000-page bill or trade agreement. That's a game not available to most of us.

But then there are (relatively) unconnected CEOs who merely make too much. Merrill Lynch CEO Stanley O'Neal made $46MM and $48MM in 2006 and 2007 respectively, then got a $161MM severance package after Merrill was sold for a song to Bank America. As noted in 'The Devils are All Here', he golfed every day, and basically had no idea what was going on related to mortgage exposure that would destroy his firm. Managers of large firms are rarely the brightest and best (exceptions usually being founders), but rather someone of steady temperament.

The CEO is often a compromise between conflicting groups. He must be blithely ignorant about the inconsistent objectives articulated to the team, such as trying to simultaneously prioritize innovation and tradition, a meritocracy that aggressively promotes racial bean-counting, or a strong sexual harassment policy and a really fun Christmas party. People who are really good at logical puzzles, who excel at something, are often not very good at managing people because they can not, or will not, suffer fools well. Thus, in spite of conspicuous examples where the highest IQ person is both an idea generator and the boss such as Larry Ellison or Bill Gates, in general the functions involve different skill sets. The result is a leader in a modern reverse dominance hierarchy who is paid to keep the peace and make people feel good, as opposed to make really important strategic and tactical decisions. It's a skill, but not one worth tens, let alone hundreds, of millions of dollars.

We don't mind inequality when we know it is for true alpha. What bothers people, and I think rightly, is when people are getting paid when they really do not have alpha, in that their ability to chair meetings, spout cliches at group functions, or golf leisurely, is something anyone could do. In contrast, if we played shortstop for the Yankees we know the team would suffer. It's a problem I don't have any solution for.

Thursday, December 2, 2010

The Advisor Weblog

The Advisor Weblog


Indian Rupee and Hong Kong Dollar

Posted: 02 Dec 2010 01:37 PM PST

Dollar was sharply lower today as stocks and commodities soar during past American session, with Wall Street indexes closing just below year highs posted past October. Over the last two days, risk sentiment has dramatically changed, sending investors against greenback. Ahead of US Payrolls, and despite data points to overcome expectations, much better than expected reading could just exacerbate current market sentiment and push dollar even lower particularly against its European rivals and commodity currencies.

On other view, Euro fall these past weeks has left most of its crosses near extreme oversold readings, supporting current bullish correction, that is still far from a trend change; EUR/INR has managed to bounce higher from 59.00 low posted yesterday, quoting at the time of writing around 50.55, and with a slightly bullish tone according to 4 hours chart: despite current candle opened above 20 SMA, indicators remain below their midlines, not yet giving bullish signs; pair needs to accelerate above 59.80 static resistance area, to extend gains towards 60.20 first, and 60.80 area, where the cross will complete a pullback to the daily ascendant trend line broke past week; supports for current session, are located at 59.30, 59.00 and the 58.30 price zone.

USD/HKD turned strongly bearish after posting a 7.7710 high, closing the day around strong 7.7659 price zone. 4 hours chart shows momentum bouncing back higher after the pair found support at the strong 7.7640 price zone, although the cross trades below its 20 SMA around 7.7670; above this last, 7.7660, 7.7690 and 7.7730 are the levels to watch, while lose of mentioned 0.7640 price zone should trigger further falls for the upcoming sessions, towards 7.7600 and 7.7565.